Blogs
In our continuing series of posts on failed or closed restaurants, many clients have asked us to review the custom and practice and the law regarding guarantees and good guy guarantees for restaurant leases.
Most restaurants in New York are owned by a limited liability company (“LLC”) or a Subchapter S corporation. That entity will set up and run the restaurant and the LLC or S corporation stock will be owned by an individual.
In negotiating the restaurant lease, all Landlords will require that the owner of the LLC or the S corporation guarantee the lease.
There are two types of lease guarantees in New York. A full or complete Guarantee for the payment of rent or additional rent by the restaurant under the lease. Under this type of Guarantee, if a restaurant fails to makelease payments for 6 months or any period of time and owes $50,000 for rent and additional rent under the lease and these monies are not paid by the restaurant, the Landlord can demand that the guarantor pay those monies and if payment is not made, the Landlord can sue the individual that owns the restaurant/guarantor for that sum of money. This is an example of an unconditional or unlimited guarantee by the restaurant owner to the Landlord.
The second type of guarantee is what is known as a “Good Guy Guarantee (“GGG”)”, which is a specialized type of guarantee which limits the payment of the guarantor under the restaurant lease, if certain conditions enumerated in the GGG are met. If the restaurant performs those conditions, the guarantor is released from its obligations under the Lease.
An example is provided below.
Example, many GGG require that the following conditions be performed by the restaurant in order for the GGG clause to come into effect and to limit the restaurant owners exposure to the Landlord for future rent. 1. the restaurant must be current on its payment of rent and additional rent, when the GGG sends a letter to the landlord indicating that the restaurant is closing, 2 . written notice must be given to the Landlord (as specified in the lease) regarding the date of the closing of the restaurant a certain number of days in advance of the closing date (usually 45 to 60 days), 3.the restaurant must be left in “broom clean” condition and 4. keys for the restaurant must be delivered to the Landlord.
Under this scenario, if all 4 conditions are satisfied, the guarantor is released from its guarantee under the Lease.
However, the restaurant remains liable for the remaining rent and additional rent due under the Lease, unless the Landlord releases the restaurant from future rent (by the parties entering into a Lease Surrender Agreement) or the restaurant’s lease is subleased or assigned to a 3rd party in accordance with the terms of the Lease and with the consent of the Landlord.
As can be seen from the above examples, a GGG is a more limited form of guarantee.
Under New York custom and practice, the guarantee whether it is a regular guarantee or a GGG can be incorporated into the terms of the lease, but it must be signed and dated by the guarantor and the guarantor is usually required to give his or her social security number and home address to the Landlord.
The guarantee or good guy guarantee can also be its own separate document and it is usually two to five pages long.
Before a restaurant closes, the lease and the guarantee, should be reviewed by an experienced attorney to determine what conditions must be met. Any clients having questions regarding a closed or failed restaurant and lease guarantees or good guy guarantees should contact Jim Shenwick at 212-541-6224 or email him at [email protected]. Jim Shenwick negotiates leases, practices bankruptcy law and represents failed or closed restaurants.
By Steven P. Taylor, J.D.
Founder of the Law Offices of Steven P. Taylor P.C.
If you become entitled to receive an inheritance after you file for bankruptcy in Indiana, it may be part of your bankruptcy estate. In a Chapter 7 bankruptcy case, it can become part of the assets that the Chapter 7 bankruptcy trustee can take unless it’s protected by an exemption. In a Chapter 13 case, receiving an inheritance does become part of the bankruptcy estate and may increase the amount you have to distribute to your unsecured creditors.
Becoming Entitled To Inheritance Within 180 Days of Filing Bankruptcy
With respect to a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, whether or not an inheritance becomes part of your bankruptcy estate depends on the timing of the inheritance. If you become entitled to the inheritance (not receive) within 180 days after you filed, the inheritance becomes the property of the Chapter 7 bankruptcy estate. 11 U.S.C. §541(a)(5)(A). You should immediately advise your attorney and are required to notify the Chapter 7 Trustee and Court. As you may recall, when you file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, a trustee is appointed to ascertain whether you have assets which the trustee can liquidate and use those funds to pay your creditors. Some of the debts get paid and the remainder will get discharge, leaving you free to move on from crushing debt.
Likewise, if you become entitled to the inheritance (not receive) within 180 days after you filed, the inheritance becomes the property of the Chapter 13 bankruptcy estate. 11 U.S.C. §541(a)(5)(A). With respect to a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, the consequences of becoming entitled to receive an inheritance also depend on the proposed distribution to unsecured creditors in your plan. In a Chapter 13 Plan, you must provide a dividend to your unsecured creditors equal to the amount they would receive as if you had filed Chapter 7. If your dividend is now insufficient, you will need to modify your plan to increase the dividend. This can be done by an increase in your monthly payments or by devoting a portion of the inheritance when received to the Chapter 13 Trustee to satisfy this requirement.
Potentially losing an inheritance can be an emotionally upsetting time; however, remember that you must be completely honest and disclose all debts and assets to the court. If the court finds that you misled the court about an inheritance, the Court could impose monetary penalties, dismiss your case and still be required to give up all or some of your inheritance. Potentially, your actions could lead to an investigation by the government for fraud, which can lead to hefty fines or incarceration. Therefore, if you do become entitled to inherit within 180 days of filing for bankruptcy, you must disclose that fact to the court and trustee by amending your bankruptcy Schedule B, and maybe C.
- You must amend Schedule B and disclosure your interest in underlying assets of the inheritance and an estimated value. If you are claiming the property as exempt in some fashion, you must also amend Schedule C.
As may be gathered, the trigger is that you have become entitled to the inheritance. It doesn’t matter when you actually collect the inheritance, even if it is after your bankruptcy is supposed to be over. The date that matters is the date entitled to the inheritance become effective (i.e., the date the decedent passed away).
Becoming Entitled to Inheritance After 180 Days of Filing Bankruptcy
With respect to a Chapter
7 bankruptcy, If you become entitled to an inheritance more than 180
days after you file, the consequences are significantly different. The
inheritance is not part of your bankruptcy assets. Therefore, a Chapter 7 trustee cannot claim
the inheritance and try to liquidate it for the benefit of your creditors. It is all yours.
With respect to a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, however, the Court and Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Trustee may still require to amend your plan due to becoming entitled to an inheritance, even if more than 180 days have passed since you filed. This is because under 11 U.S.C. §1306(a)(1), your Chapter 13 bankruptcy assets include all assets acquired until your case is closed, dismissed or converted. While technically, you are not required to pay an increased dividend to your unsecured creditors by reason of becoming entitled to this inheritance; the Chapter 13 Trustee will require you increase the dividend to the unsecured creditors by some amount. (By the way, this can happen when your income and assets increase for any reason during the Chapter 13 bankruptcy repayment plan period, from three to five years.)
Steps to Take to Keep Inheritance
If you are aware that you are the beneficiary of a will of a person who may be passing within 180 days of your anticipated bankruptcy filing date, you may want to suggest that your entitlement be left to you as a beneficiary of a spendthrift trust. Some courts have held that a true spendthrift trust is not part of the bankruptcy estate. Contrary to conventional wisdom, spendthrift trusts are not solely for the well-to-do. Having this discussion with a loved ones who want you to have something with they pass can honor their wishes and allow you to avoid the hassle of dealing with bankruptcy trustee in a bankruptcy proceeding.
Find an Attorney
If you file for bankruptcy in Indiana and receive an inheritance, bankruptcy laws require that you disclose the new assets to the court and trustee. If you anticipate that you may inherit property while in bankruptcy that you really want to keep, you may wish to discuss your case with an experienced Indiana attorney to determine how to protect your inheritance from bankruptcy or how an inheritance will be treated during the bankruptcy.
Advertisements
__ATA.cmd.push(function() {
__ATA.initSlot('atatags-26942-5dbc60b436ea5', {
collapseEmpty: 'before',
sectionId: '26942',
location: 120,
width: 300,
height: 250
});
});
__ATA.cmd.push(function() {
__ATA.initSlot('atatags-114160-5dbc60b436eaa', {
collapseEmpty: 'before',
sectionId: '114160',
location: 130,
width: 300,
height: 250
});
});
Military Service Members Can Obtain Free Credit Monitoring Starting on October 31, 2019
(reprint from FTC) Starting October 31, 2019, many members of the military will have access to free electronic credit monitoring, which can help them spot identity theft.
In response to a new FTC Rule implementing a 2018 law, the nationwide credit reporting agencies—Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion—are providing free electronic credit monitoring services to active duty service members and National Guard members. Credit monitoring services can alert consumers to mistakes or problems with their credit reports that might stem from the unauthorized use of their personal information to obtain credit.
For details on how to sign up for the free credit monitoring, go to the websites for each of the credit reporting agencies. For information about how to dispute an error in a credit report, read Disputing Errors on Your Credit Report. To spot signs of, or recover from, identity theft, visit Identitytheft.gov.
The Federal Trade Commission works to promote competition, and protect and educate consumers. You can learn more about consumer topics and file a consumer complaint online or by calling 1-877-FTC-HELP (382-4357). subscribe to press releases for the latest FTC news and resources.
Contact Information
MEDIA CONTACT:
Juliana Gruenwald Henderson at [email protected]
Office of Public Affairs
202-326-2924
For Consumers
MUSINGS FROM DIANE:
Some of you may know that my husband is a Vietnam vet (Marines). It sickens me when I read about sleazes who rip off our veterans. These young men or woman have elected to put themselves in harms way (just like our first responders). It is beyond me why anyone would to steal from another, but unfortunately that is the world we live in. Learn to protect yourself and others around you by diligently monitoring your credit and taking responsibility for other important financial issues.
How Can I Help You?
The post Military Can Obtain Free Credit Monitoring appeared first on Diane L. Drain - Phoenix Bankruptcy & Foreclosure Attorney.
Restaurants and Workouts with Creditors
Many readers of our blog, who read last week's post titled
“Restaurant Closings in New York City and Bankruptcy”
have asked us to do a post regarding workouts with creditors
after the restaurant has closed.
Let's review a typical fact pattern, that we see regarding failed restaurants.
The restaurant is owned by an LLC or a subchapter S corporation and the member’s
interest in the LLC or the stock in the S corporation are 100% owned by Mr. X.
The restaurant closes and the following debts are due and owing:
Suppliers or trade vendors are owed $150,000
The landlord is owed $75,000, which amount is subject to a “guaranty” or a “good guy guaranty” by Mr. X.
$45,000 is owed for New York State sales tax.
The FICA/Futa tax penalty for the employee component (trust fund money) is $30,000 and
Former employees of the restaurant are owed $20,000 im past due wages.
For purposes of this example the restaurant has elected to close and not
file for Chapter 7 or Chapter 11 bankruptcy.
What should the restaurant owner (Mr X) do? Let’s analyze how each debt
and how it should be treated.
First, with respect to the suppliers or trade vendors, if those debts have not been guaranteed
by Mr X. they do not have to be paid because they are the obligation of the restaurant.
If the suppliers or vendors are not paid within 30 to 45 days of the restaurants closing,
they can sue the restaurant and they will be able to obtain a judgment against the restaurant,
but not against Mr. X.
Second, the debt to the landlord is an obligation of the restaurant and of the guarantor, Mr X. If the landlord is not paid,
the Landlord will sue the restaurant and Mr X. Since the restaurant is closed, it does not need to be concerned about a
judgment from the Landlord, but the judgment against Mr. X would need to be addressed thru a workout with the landlord
or by a bankruptcy filing by Mr. X. The debt to the former Landlord should be addressed by Mr. X after the payment or a
workout with New York State sales tax and the FICA/FUTA tax penalty, for reasons discussed below.
Third, the $45,000 owed to New York State sales tax is a trust fund or a responsible person tax and it would not
be dischargeable in a bankruptcy by Mr. X and an arrangement should be made to pay that tax through the sale
of the restaurants furniture fixture & equipment or the collection of its accounts receivable, or from Mr. X’s savings.
Fourth, the FICA/FUTA $30,000 tax is a trust fund and similar to sales tax it would not be dischargeable
in Mr. X’s bankruptcy filing and it should be paid or payment arrangements should be made with the IRS
Fifth, under New York State law past due wages due to former employees are an obligation of the restaurant and
Mr X personally. If these wages are not paid by Mr. X the former employees can sue him and obtain a judgment,
but the judgment will be dischargeable in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy filing by Mr. X.
With respect to the terms of a workout there are two ways to work out a payment plan with a creditor, one is
with a lump-sum payment and the other is a series of payments over time, otherwise known as an “installment agreement”
or an “out of court settlement or workout”.
A creditor will give a larger discount for a lump sum payment, than an installment payment. For example,
if a creditor is owed $30,000, Mr. X may be able to negotiate a lump sum payment of $5,000 as a final and full payment,
with a release from the creditor to Mr. X.
In an installment payment arrangement Mr. X would agree to pay a creditor who is due $30,000, $10,000 overtime,
in ten $1000 monthly installment payments.
Restaurant owners with a failed or a closed restaurant should consult with an experienced bankruptcy or in debtor-creditor attorney
as soon as possible in the process. Jim Shenwick, Esq. can be contacted at 212-541-6224 or at [email protected]
Worthless Student Loan Debt Relief Scam – Consolidation and Forgiveness
Never pay upfront for “help” with your student loans
Student loan trap
According to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) scammers stole millions from innocent student loan borrowers who were doing their best to workout their student loans. These sleazes lied to innocent borrowers, saying that for $1,000 upfront, they could permanently reduce or eliminate the monthly payments.
Lied about connection with U.S. Department of Education or the loan servicers
The FTC alleged that the defendants’ companies bilked millions from people trying to lower or eliminate their student loan debt. The defendants marketed on social media platforms, including Facebook. According to the FTC’s complaint, they misrepresented that they were affiliated with the U.S. Department of Education or the loan servicers, and falsely claimed that consumers who paid an upfront fee of up to $1,000 were qualified or approved for permanently reduced monthly payments or loan forgiveness. In fact, the complaint alleged, the defendants had no affiliation with the U.S. Department of Education and operated a service that provided no relief.
The defendants’ Los Angeles-based companies used the following names: Alliance Document Preparation, LLC; EZ Doc Preps; Grads Aid; First Document Aid; SBS Capital Group, LLC; Grads United Discharge; SBB Holdings, LLC; Allied Doc Prep; Post Grad Services; United Legal Center, LLC; Post Grad Aid; Alumni Aid Assistance; United Legal Discharge; United Legal Center, Inc.; Grads Doc Prep, LLC; Academic Aid Center; Academic Protection; Academy Doc Prep; and Academic Discharge.
HOW TO PROTECT YOURSELF FROM STUDENT LOAN SCAMS:
Student Loan Consolidation Scam: What To Do (reprint from Forbes article)
- If a student loan company says it has a “relationship” with the U.S. Department of Education, don’t work with them.
- Legitimate student loan companies clearly disclose that they are independent companies that are not affiliated with the U.S. Department of Education.
- Never pay a fee for student loan consolidation. Student loan consolidation is completely free through the federal government.
- Remember, student loan consolidation helps you organize your student loans, but does not lower your interest rate or your monthly payment. Visit Studentloans.gov or call 1-800-557-7394 for more information on student loan consolidation.
- If you want to lower your interest rate or monthly payment, then refinance student loans. Plus, student loan refinancing rates just got cheaper.
Student Loan Forgiveness Scam: What To Do
- No third party student loan debt company will “forgive” your student loans.
- Don’t pay an upfront fee for student loan forgiveness.
- This scam sounds like Public Service Loan Forgiveness, which is a federal program for public servants with federal student loans. Income-driven repayment plans also can offer student loan forgiveness for federal student loans.
- You can report the scam to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB). You can also report the scam to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) or call 1-877-FTC-HELP (1-877-382-4357).
- If your goal is to lower your student loan interest rate and monthly payment today, the best way to lower your student loan interest rate is to refinance your student loans. This student loan refinance calculator shows how much you can save when you refinance student loans.
FTC sends more than $5.4 million to people who paid for worthless student loan debt relief.
The post Worthless Student Loan Debt Relief – Consolidation & Forgiveness appeared first on Diane L. Drain - Phoenix Bankruptcy & Foreclosure Attorney.
Worthless Student Loan Debt Relief Scam – Consolidation and Forgiveness
Never pay upfront for “help” with your student loans
Student loan trap
According to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) scammers stole millions from innocent student loan borrowers who were doing their best to workout their student loans. These sleazes lied to innocent borrowers, saying that for $1,000 upfront, they could permanently reduce or eliminate the monthly payments.
Lied about connection with U.S. Department of Education or the loan servicers
The FTC alleged that the defendants’ companies bilked millions from people trying to lower or eliminate their student loan debt. The defendants marketed on social media platforms, including Facebook. According to the FTC’s complaint, they misrepresented that they were affiliated with the U.S. Department of Education or the loan servicers, and falsely claimed that consumers who paid an upfront fee of up to $1,000 were qualified or approved for permanently reduced monthly payments or loan forgiveness. In fact, the complaint alleged, the defendants had no affiliation with the U.S. Department of Education and operated a service that provided no relief.
The defendants’ Los Angeles-based companies used the following names: Alliance Document Preparation, LLC; EZ Doc Preps; Grads Aid; First Document Aid; SBS Capital Group, LLC; Grads United Discharge; SBB Holdings, LLC; Allied Doc Prep; Post Grad Services; United Legal Center, LLC; Post Grad Aid; Alumni Aid Assistance; United Legal Discharge; United Legal Center, Inc.; Grads Doc Prep, LLC; Academic Aid Center; Academic Protection; Academy Doc Prep; and Academic Discharge.
HOW TO PROTECT YOURSELF FROM STUDENT LOAN SCAMS:
Student Loan Consolidation Scam: What To Do (reprint from Forbes article)
- If a student loan company says it has a “relationship” with the U.S. Department of Education, don’t work with them.
- Legitimate student loan companies clearly disclose that they are independent companies that are not affiliated with the U.S. Department of Education.
- Never pay a fee for student loan consolidation. Student loan consolidation is completely free through the federal government.
- Remember, student loan consolidation helps you organize your student loans, but does not lower your interest rate or your monthly payment. Visit Studentloans.gov or call 1-800-557-7394 for more information on student loan consolidation.
- If you want to lower your interest rate or monthly payment, then refinance student loans. Plus, student loan refinancing rates just got cheaper.
Student Loan Forgiveness Scam: What To Do
- No third party student loan debt company will “forgive” your student loans.
- Don’t pay an upfront fee for student loan forgiveness.
- This scam sounds like Public Service Loan Forgiveness, which is a federal program for public servants with federal student loans. Income-driven repayment plans also can offer student loan forgiveness for federal student loans.
- You can report the scam to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB). You can also report the scam to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) or call 1-877-FTC-HELP (1-877-382-4357).
- If your goal is to lower your student loan interest rate and monthly payment today, the best way to lower your student loan interest rate is to refinance your student loans. This student loan refinance calculator shows how much you can save when you refinance student loans.
FTC sends more than $5.4 million to people who paid for worthless student loan debt relief.
The post Worthless Student Loan Debt Relief – Consolidation & Forgiveness appeared first on Diane L. Drain - Phoenix Bankruptcy & Foreclosure Attorney.
In the earlier series on real estate closing, Wynn at Law, LLC mentioned easements. In fact, we bring up the topic every time we review a title or write an article about one. The reason is simple, just like the old proverb that good fences make good neighbors: Clearly defined easements keep property owners out of court.
An easement on a property allows a landowner to grant access to a part of his or her property. You grant access without giving up ownership of that part of the property. It’s a binding agreement. Where we see this commonly throughout southeast Wisconsin is allowing access to a walking path, a driveway, a community pier, or a utility line crossing the property. Without an easement in place for access to such things, anyone attempting to access the path, pier, driveway or utility pole would be trespassing on the property. You can see the legal ramifications.
That means: Talk to your attorney anytime the word comes up. Here are a few spots in which the topic may come up.
If you are buying a property
Two easement issues Wynn at Law, LLC sees frequently are easements for driveways and for lake rights or lake access. When there are disputes over the area of the easement, or the size or the situations for which the property can be used, it can sour a neighborhood. Nobody wants to be ‘that neighbor,’ especially when you’re new to the neighborhood. By the way, if a lender is involved, the lender may take issues with driveway easements. Driveway easements require you to have legal access to your property. Imagine the difficulty clearing up the easement specifics after the closing.
If you are selling a property
When you know of an easement exists, you should disclose that to potential buyers on the real estate condition report. If you do not have a written easement in place or it is not recorded with the Register of Deeds Office, Wynn at Law, LLC can assist you in drafting and recording the easement.
Your relationship with your neighbors is the important aspect of easements. It is important to have a lawyer review easements on your property because it is your property.
Image by Anna Koldunova, used with permission.
The post In real estate law, there’s no such thing as an ‘easy’ easement appeared first on Wynn at Law, LLC.
In the earlier series on real estate closing, Wynn at Law, LLC mentioned easements. In fact, we bring up the topic every time we review a title or write an article about one. The reason is simple, just like the old proverb that good fences make good neighbors: Clearly defined easements keep property owners out of court.
An easement on a property allows a landowner to grant access to a part of his or her property. You grant access without giving up ownership of that part of the property. It’s a binding agreement. Where we see this commonly throughout southeast Wisconsin is allowing access to a walking path, a driveway, a community pier, or a utility line crossing the property. Without an easement in place for access to such things, anyone attempting to access the path, pier, driveway or utility pole would be trespassing on the property. You can see the legal ramifications.
That means: Talk to your attorney anytime the word comes up. Here are a few spots in which the topic may come up.
If you are buying a property
Two easement issues Wynn at Law, LLC sees frequently are easements for driveways and for lake rights or lake access. When there are disputes over the area of the easement, or the size or the situations for which the property can be used, it can sour a neighborhood. Nobody wants to be ‘that neighbor,’ especially when you’re new to the neighborhood. By the way, if a lender is involved, the lender may take issues with driveway easements. Driveway easements require you to have legal access to your property. Imagine the difficulty clearing up the easement specifics after the closing.
If you are selling a property
When you know of an easement exists, you should disclose that to potential buyers on the real estate condition report. If you do not have a written easement in place or it is not recorded with the Register of Deeds Office, Wynn at Law, LLC can assist you in drafting and recording the easement.
Your relationship with your neighbors is the important aspect of easements. It is important to have a lawyer review easements on your property because it is your property.
Image by Anna Koldunova, used with permission.
The post In real estate law, there’s no such thing as an ‘easy’ easement appeared first on Wynn at Law, LLC.
Restaurant Closings in New York City and BankruptcyAs reported by many newspapers and websites, a significant number of restaurants are closing in New York City. These closings are due to the high cost of rent, insurance, overhead and the increase in the minimum wage to $15 per hour for the restaurant staff. A restaurant consultant who meet with me stated that a Ray Kroc associate told an individual not to open a restaurant unless they were prepared to clean the bathroom and wipe the floor themselves due to the thin margins in many restaurants. At Shenwick & Associates, we have seen a significant uptick in bankruptcy filings by restaurant and restaurant owners and we have developed a legal strategy to deal with these situations.We focus on the financial issues related to the restaurant first and then to the owner of the restaurant second. Most restaurants are owned by LLC or Subchapter S corporations. We first review the assets and liabilities for the restaurant and a recent budget showing revenue and expenses for the year to date. We review that information with the owner and determining whether the restaurant should close or file for bankruptcy and we then focus on issues related to the owner of the restaurant.Restaurants are eligible to file for chapter 7 or chapter 11 bankruptcy. Chapter 7 is a liquidation where the restaurant is closed or chapter 11 is a reorganization where the business can attempt to reorganize its debts. In the Southern and Eastern District of New York (Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens and Nassau county) historically on average only one out of 10 businesses are able to successfully reorganize (file and confirm a chapter 11 plan of reorganization). There are many reasons for the low percentage of success, but many of those factors related to the cost and expense of filing chapter 11 bankruptcy and the inability to obtain financing and capital from third parties or banks.The option that most restaurant owners face is either to close the restaurant or file Chapter 7 bankruptcy for the LLC or S Corporation that owns the restaurant. In Chapter 7 bankruptcy a bankruptcy trustee closes the restaurant and liquidates any inventory, furniture fixture or equipment and attempts to collect accounts receivable. The chapter 7 trustee then takes those monies, if any and distributes them to creditors after paying legal fees and court costs.It's the restaurant does not have significant amounts of furniture fixture or equipment or accounts receivable, the owner may be better off closing the restaurant itself and selling or auctioning off any furniture fixture and equipment and attempting to collect its own accounts receivable. Additionally, if the restaurant lease has a term of 3 years or more and is below market the restaurant owner may be able to assign (sell) the lease to a 3rd party. A Chapter 7 bankruptcy trustee is permitted to bring lawsuits to recover monies that may have been paid to third parties ( preference actions) or recover money or property paid to a third party ( fraudulent conveyance actions) and the bankruptcy trustee will want to review the books and records for the restaurant, its checking account and tax returns. The owner of the restaurant will have to go to one meeting at the courthouse (called the 341 hearing) and cooperate with the bankruptcy trustee. These factors often affect whether a restaurant will file for chapter 7 bankruptcy or just close.Notwithstanding the fact that the restaurant is owned by an LLC or Subchapter S corporation, members of the LLC, including the officers, directors, shareholders or the individuals that signed the checks may be liable for certain debts of the restaurant after it closes (discussed below). Some of those debts may be “responsible person taxes” which are trust fund taxes such as sales tax or FICA/FUTA taxes withheld from an employee's wages or the FICA/FUTA tax penalties. Sales tax and FICA/FUTA taxes are not dischargeable in personal bankruptcy, so those debts should be paid prior to the restaurant closing or paid from the sale of furniture, fixtures and equipment, collection of accounts receivable or from the sale of the lease. Next, if a member of the LLC or a shareholder guaranteed a lease obligation, or guaranteed debts to a supplier, they be personally liable ( discussed below). There are 2 types of lease guaranties, good guy guaranties and lease guarantees and the type of guaranty can affect the amount owed by the restaurant owner. If a supplier to the restaurant is not paid, the restaurant is generally liable, however in certain instances, the supplier will look for a “deeper pocket” and sue the individual arguing “alter ego” or “piercing the corporate veil” and attempt to sue not only the restaurant but the owner of the restaurant as well.The owner of the restaurant, may also be liable personally for wages not paid to the restaurant staff under the New York State Business Corporation law.A restaurant owner with significant business debts may need to file a Chapter 7 bankruptcy or attempt an out-of-court workout with respect to the monies that it owes. To determine whether a restaurant owner should file bankruptcy or attempt to do an out-of-court workout with its creditors, we need to see a list of assets or property that the restaurant owner owns, a list of liabilities or money or property owed to third parties and an after-tax monthly budget, showing what the restaurant owner earns what it pays in personal and business expenses.Unfortunately, in many instances after the restaurant is closed, the restaurant owner needs to file a Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 personal bankruptcy and James Shenwick is available to help address these issues. Jim Shenwick 212 541 6224, [email protected]